• Contact us
  • Advertising Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Wednesday, July 16, 2025
26 °c
Agartala
enewstime
  • Home
  • News
    • Northeast
    • National
    • International
    • Tripura News
  • Sports
    Kokrajhar rolls out red carpet for 134th Indian Oil Durand Cup trophies

    Kokrajhar rolls out red carpet for 134th Indian Oil Durand Cup trophies

    India women will be testing all departments before ODI WC: Anjum Chopra ahead of England series

    India women will be testing all departments before ODI WC: Anjum Chopra ahead of England series

    Jadeja should've played more strokes, people will forget this 61 not out: Surinder Khanna

    Jadeja should've played more strokes, people will forget this 61 not out: Surinder Khanna

    USMNT to meet Ecuador, Australia in October friendlies

    USMNT to meet Ecuador, Australia in October friendlies

    FIFA Prez Infantino has done a great job, says Trump after Club WC final

    FIFA Prez Infantino has done a great job, says Trump after Club WC final

    Aditi finishes T-28 as Australian Grace Kim wins Evian Championship

    Aditi finishes T-28 as Australian Grace Kim wins Evian Championship

    Cricket icons set to return to spotlight in World Championship of Legends

    Cricket icons set to return to spotlight in World Championship of Legends

    I have no words for players, they all deserve this: Maresca after Chelsea's Club WC triumph

    I have no words for players, they all deserve this: Maresca after Chelsea's Club WC triumph

    Golf: Aditi Ashok lies seventh at halfway mark in Evian Championship

    Golf: Aditi Ashok lies seventh at halfway mark in Evian Championship

  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Features
  • TendersNew
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Northeast
    • National
    • International
    • Tripura News
  • Sports
    Kokrajhar rolls out red carpet for 134th Indian Oil Durand Cup trophies

    Kokrajhar rolls out red carpet for 134th Indian Oil Durand Cup trophies

    India women will be testing all departments before ODI WC: Anjum Chopra ahead of England series

    India women will be testing all departments before ODI WC: Anjum Chopra ahead of England series

    Jadeja should've played more strokes, people will forget this 61 not out: Surinder Khanna

    Jadeja should've played more strokes, people will forget this 61 not out: Surinder Khanna

    USMNT to meet Ecuador, Australia in October friendlies

    USMNT to meet Ecuador, Australia in October friendlies

    FIFA Prez Infantino has done a great job, says Trump after Club WC final

    FIFA Prez Infantino has done a great job, says Trump after Club WC final

    Aditi finishes T-28 as Australian Grace Kim wins Evian Championship

    Aditi finishes T-28 as Australian Grace Kim wins Evian Championship

    Cricket icons set to return to spotlight in World Championship of Legends

    Cricket icons set to return to spotlight in World Championship of Legends

    I have no words for players, they all deserve this: Maresca after Chelsea's Club WC triumph

    I have no words for players, they all deserve this: Maresca after Chelsea's Club WC triumph

    Golf: Aditi Ashok lies seventh at halfway mark in Evian Championship

    Golf: Aditi Ashok lies seventh at halfway mark in Evian Championship

  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Features
  • TendersNew
No Result
View All Result
enewstime
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Features
  • Tenders
Home Business

Economists say freebies make sense only if a state budget has revenue surplus

ENEWSTIME Desk by ENEWSTIME Desk
August 21, 2022
in Business
30
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

VENKATACHARI JAGANNATHAN

 

 

With the issue of freebies announced by political parties being heard by the Supreme Court, economists are of the view that if there is revenue surplus in the budget then freebies could be implemented.

 

In simple terms, what is applicable at the home front is equally applicable for the governments – spend if there is a surplus, said economists queried on freebies and subsidies.

 

“Political parties can announce freebies, subsidies as poll promises. But such poll promises – freebies/subsidies – should be implemented only if there is a revenue surplus in the state budget,” K.R. Shanmugam, Director, Madras School of Economics, told IANS.

 

The state and the central governments are welfare governments and welfare schemes cannot be prohibited, he added.

 

The current debate about freebies is that they are announced by political parties as part of their poll manifestoes. There are also free schemes implemented by the governments which were not mentioned in the ruling party’s manifestos.

 

The one way out is that the state budget should comply with the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBM) and there should be revenue surplus in the budget.

 

“Implementing freebies and subsidies announced in the poll manifestoes can be allowed if there is a revenue surplus in the state budget,” Shanmugam reiterated.

 

But what is happening at the ground level is that the state governments borrow to implement these freebies which in turn adds to their debt burden.

 

According to Shanmugam, a sustainable debt: state gross domestic product (SGDP) ratio will be 20 per cent.

 

Indian states should curtail their wasteful expenditure to control their debt and improve their fiscal position.

 

Freebies and welfare schemes of state governments are funded mainly from liquor tax revenues which is like robbing the family head and giving it to his family members.

 

“The issue of subsidies and freebies has come to the fore with the collapse of the Sri Lankan economy and political parties announcing freebies as their poll promises,” Economist Gowri Ramachandran told IANS.

 

According to her, freebies are not actually free, but a burden on other taxpayers.

 

It is a welfare economy and is the duty of the state government to protect the marginalised sections of the society.

 

Ramachandran said freebies/subsidies had to be accommodated in the budget outlays.

 

She said freebies/subsidies have to be dealt with in a calculated manner without foregoing fiscal deficit, macroeconomic stability while bringing up the marginalised sections of the society.

 

“Subsidies are of two kinds — good and bad. The good ones do not impact other sectors, distort prices while uplifting the targeted populace, while bad subsidies have a negative effect on the other sectors,” Shanmugam said.

 

According to him, subsidy is a fiscal instrument in the hands of the government.

 

Shanmugam said if the target group is identified and assistance is provided to them for their upliftment then it is a good subsidy.

 

However, if it distorts the price – for example free electricity – then it is bad.

 

Electricity is a scarce commodity and offering it free will increase the usage which in turn would distort the prices in other sectors.

 

“Similarly, the free bus ride for women in the government city and town buses in Tamil Nadu is not a targeted one as those who can afford the bus will also travel free,” Shanmugam added.

 

According to Ramachandran, the expenditure and the overall beneficial impact has to be weighed in the case of welfare schemes.

 

She added that freebies play a role in attaining the UN Sustainable Development Goals like zero hunger, good health and wellbeing and gender equality.

 

“In all these touch points freebies play an important role,” she said.

 

Agreeing that the state’s alternate sources of income are limited, Shanmugam said: “Perhaps the Central government can allow the states to levy Income Tax on their citizens. There are states who are complaining that their citizens contribute a huge amount of taxes to the Central government but get only a small share from the Centre.”

 

(Venkatachari Jagannathan can be reached at v.jagannathan@ians.in)

Related Posts

Himachal CM meets Finance Commission head, seeks assistance
Business

Himachal CM meets Finance Commission head, seeks assistance

July 15, 2025
Dabba trading: ED conducts raids in Mumbai; Rs 3.3 crore cash, luxury items seized
Business

Dabba trading: ED conducts raids in Mumbai; Rs 3.3 crore cash, luxury items seized

July 15, 2025
India’s average inflation falls 3 pc in last 11 years under PM Modi government
Business

India’s average inflation falls 3 pc in last 11 years under PM Modi government

July 15, 2025
Sensex, Nifty open higher amid positive domestic cues
Business

Sensex, Nifty open higher amid positive domestic cues

July 15, 2025
Sculptors of TN's Tiruppur seek dedicated industrial cluster to preserve heritage craft
Business

Sculptors of TN's Tiruppur seek dedicated industrial cluster to preserve heritage craft

July 14, 2025
Falling wholesale inflation in India to boost demand and growth: Industry
Business

Falling wholesale inflation in India to boost demand and growth: Industry

July 14, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
D-2050 D-2050 D-2050
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

About us

Enewstime.in is run by an individual – a Journalist by profession of Tripura with the active help of several journos including senior journalists of the State. On top of that, Enewstime.in being a subscriber of IANS news agency, we have plenty of multi-choice topics to offer to our esteemed readers. Enewstime.in is a venture reach global audience from a tiny State Tripura.

Latest News

‘Love hormone’ can fix mood changes in women with disturbed sleep

Dr Jitendra Singh bats for holistic healthcare, calls for restoring doctor-patient trust

Smriti Irani taking a sabbatical from politics? 'Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi' actress reacts

Himachal CM meets Finance Commission head, seeks assistance

Kokrajhar rolls out red carpet for 134th Indian Oil Durand Cup trophies

WHO recommends twice-a-year lenacapavir jab to boost global HIV prevention

Contact us

19, Old Thana Road. Banamalipur. PO. Agartala. Pin code 799001. Tripura (West), India.

Email: enewstime2017@gmail.com

Wa: 8794548041

  • Contact us
  • Advertising Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2025 Designed & Developed with ❤️ by Provibe Media LLP

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Northeast
    • National
    • International
    • Tripura News
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Features
  • Tenders

© 2025 Designed & Developed with ❤️ by Provibe Media LLP