Information Commission of Tripura has imposed a penalty on a senior Tribal Welfare Department official for withholding documents requested under the RTI Act by the Chakma Development Foundation of India, citing procedural violations, an unjustified refusal and a delay of more than three years.
At A Glance
-
Tripura Chief Information Commissioner Binoy Shankar Mishra imposes the maximum Rs 25,000 fine on S. Prabhu.
-
The officer withheld information sought under RTI about the Chakma Customary Laws Act, 2022.
-
The Information Commission identifies a delay of 1,131 days and violations of statutory procedures.
Tripura Chief Information Commissioner Binoy Shankar Mishra has imposed a Rs 25,000 penalty on Tribal Welfare Department Additional Secretary S. Prabhu for violating provisions of the Right to Information (RTI) Act. The penalty relates to his refusal to disclose official documents concerning the Chakma Customary Laws Act, 2022.
The Information Commission found that Prabhu had unlawfully withheld the requested information, failed to follow established procedures and provided incorrect, incomplete and misleading responses to the applicant.
The Rs 25,000 fine represents the maximum penalty prescribed under Section 20(1) of the RTI Act.
Chakma Foundation’s RTI Application
The case originated from an RTI application submitted in August 2023 by Jagdish Rawat, Office Secretary of the Chakma Development Foundation of India (CDFI).
Through the application, Rawat sought several documents connected with the Chakma Customary Laws Act, 2022. These included copies of official communications, departmental opinions and representations submitted by Chakma organisations. He also requested certified copies of relevant records.
However, S. Prabhu, who was serving as the Public Information Officer (PIO) at the time, rejected the application.
He reportedly justified the refusal by stating that the matter was pending before the State Legislature. Prabhu also forwarded the RTI application to Chakma Miley Jodha, a private organisation identified as the Chakma Women’s Association, seeking the requested information from it.
Information Commission Rejects Officer’s Justification
After hearing the appeal filed by Rawat, the Information Commission found no legally sustainable grounds for denying access to the requested documents.
The Commission observed that the officer had failed to establish any legislative privilege that could justify withholding the information.
It also ruled that forwarding an RTI application to a private organisation violated the statutory framework governing access to information.
The Commission raised another procedural concern regarding Prabhu’s handling of the application. It found that he had acted both as the PIO and the First Appellate Authority.
Consequently, he had effectively reviewed his own earlier decision. The Commission considered this contrary to established legal principles governing the RTI mechanism.

It further concluded that Prabhu had not demonstrated reasonable diligence in performing his official responsibilities. He also failed to cite any valid statutory provision to support his decision to withhold the documents.
Delay of 1,131 Days Leads to Maximum Penalty
The Commission’s order recorded a delay of 1,131 days in providing the requested information.
Under the RTI Act, the prescribed penalty for such a violation stands at Rs 250 per day. Based on the recorded delay, the calculated amount would have exceeded Rs 2.82 lakh.
However, Section 20(1) of the Act limits the maximum penalty to Rs 25,000.
The Commission therefore imposed the highest permissible fine on the officer.
It also observed that Prabhu had knowingly furnished incorrect, incomplete and misleading information to the applicant.
The order reinforces the statutory responsibility of public information officers to provide requested information in accordance with the RTI Act and follow the prescribed appeal procedures. (Edited by Enewstime Desk)
